Homemade Valentine’s Day Mints

I had a vision of mints the other day.

Cute, mini, glittery, heart mints for Valentine’s Day.

They are soo much better than those conversation hearts.

First you need a teeny tiny heart cookie cutter (I used this mini heart fondant cutter) or you could use a mini heart mold. I believe using a mold is the typical way to make mints.. but I didn’t have one so I improvised. This way works just fine!


For these hearts you can use a basic mint or cream cheese mint recipe. You first mix 2 Tbs softened butter, 1 Tbs Crisco, 1-2 tsp Peppermint Extract and 1/2 pound of powdered sugar. It should be clumpy. Add 1 Tbs hot water at a time (usually around 2-3 Tbs hot water total) until the mixture can easily be rolled into a ball without being too sticky.

If you want to make different colored or flavored mints, separate your mixture and add your desired food coloring or flavor.

Roll each color into a ball and place on a cutting board with powdered sugar. Roll out each ball flat until it reaches about 1/4 inch.

You want to wait about 10-15 minutes before you cut out your hearts or they will be too soft to handle.

Make sure you dip your cookie cutter in powdered sugar.

The trick to not get the hearts stuck in the cookie cutter is to press down quick and hard. If the mint gets stuck in the cutter, either wait a few minutes longer before continuing or just tap the cookie cutter on the cutting board until your mint comes out.


These are chocolate mints. I added a bit of cocoa powder to the mixture.


You want to then wait another 10-15 minutes after you’ve cut out your hearts. This makes it super easy to remove the surrounding dough and your hearts will come right out. If you want to add Edible Glitter now’s the time. Then place your mints on a cookie sheet and leave out for a few hours.

Then share with your friends and family! Happy Valentine’s Day!



Get the latest delicious goodness straight to your inbox!


  1. Melissa P says

    Made these this morning with my 4 yr old. He and i had fun kneading in different colors. They kept getting stuck in the little cutter so I had use a blunt toothpick to gently push them out. Oh my these are yummy! My son loved eating the scraps! Thanks for posting. I posted a pic on Facebook and now everyone wanted your recipe! I sent them back here! Love this!

  2. Jessica says

    Hi – Just seeing these from Pinterest. I am confused as to the reference to the basic mint recipes (cream cheese in link) and then I need to add butter, crisco, more peppermint, and sugar? Or is it an either/or? Thanks!

  3. Cindy says

    This conjures up all kinds of ideas. I think I will make heart shaped croutons for our tomato soup.

  4. Emily says

    @ Shannon: This is just a basic mint recipe. Follow the link in the post to a cream cheese mint recipe.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *